Our History

Good Old Gold is a family owned and operated business established by Helen and John Weingarten in 1980 and online since 1998. Helen and John's passion for estate jewelry and coins inspired their three children to pursue different niches in the jewelry industry. Jonathan's knowledge in diamond education, Susan's enthusiasm for gemstones, and Amy's creative custom jewelry designs together created different avenues for the business to grow and serve the customer. Although Jonathan has ventured off in pursuit of his own dreams, Helen with the help of her daughters, and three generations of family members are continuing to guide the business with the same philosophy it was started with.

From the beginning, we have strived to serve and educate our clients, making each customer feel like family and helping them make the most informed purchase possible. Let us take care of all your jewelry needs whether you are purchasing or maintaining your jewelry. We have a knowledgeable and professional sales staff and our in house jeweler has over 30 years’ experience. From the simplest repair to a complete redesign of your existing piece, we will make sure that you fall in love with your jewelry all over again.

Conveniently located on the South Shore of Long Island in Massapequa Park, New York, we take pride in serving our clients both near and far. For our customers who are unable to visit our showroom, we strive to treat them as if they were here in our store with the use of images and HD videos.

Good Old Gold has a large selection of diamonds, bridal jewelry, and one of a kind estate pieces.

Over the years we have grown from a small kiosk to the store we are today. 

March 1982

Store 1992

Store Today